LATEST IN NEWS
Saiyaara Sparks Debate: Is Mohit Suri`s Latest a Nod to a Korean Classic?
Updated on: 21 July, 2025 12:57 PM IST |Amruta Karulkar
Saiyaara a Korean Remake?
Mohit Suri`s recent directorial, Saiyaara, starring debutantes Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda, has taken the box office by storm since its release on Friday, July 18. The musical romance opened to an impressive ₹21 crore, an exceptional feat for newcomers, and has been praised for its soulful music, emotional story, and strong performances. However, amidst its success, a noticeable buzz has emerged online, with many drawing strong parallels between Saiyaara and the 2004 South Korean film "A Moment to Remember."
This central theme of a couple battling early-onset Alzheimer`s is strikingly similar to the plot of John H. Lee`s acclaimed 2004 Korean romantic drama, "A Moment to Remember." This classic film follows Su-jin (Son Ye-jin) and Chul-soo (Jung Woo-sung) as their relationship is tested by Su-jin`s diagnosis. The film is celebrated for its emotional depth, particularly how Chul-soo supports Su-jin in holding onto their shared memories. A Moment to Remember has inspired several unofficial adaptations globally, leading to the current speculation surrounding Saiyaara.
Also Read: Mohit Suri Reveals Many Filmmakers Dissuaded Him Against Making Saiyaara
However, some have come to Mohit Suri`s defence, arguing that while themes may be similar, the execution and cultural context offer a fresh perspective. One user remarked, “It`s a well-made adaptation even if it is. But I don`t think so, This alzheimers/disease-ridden love story is a common trope among many love stories and it works since it provides a direct emotional connect.”
As of now, the makers of Saiyaara, including director Mohit Suri and producer Akshaye Widhani of Yash Raj Films, have not issued any official statement addressing these comparisons or confirming if the film is an adaptation. Saiyaara is credited to writers Sankalp Sadanah and Rohan Shankar, with previous reports indicating it was envisioned as a "contemporary" Indian love story. Despite the ongoing debate, Saiyaara continues to garner praise for its performances and its chart-topping music, composed by talents like Mithoon and Vishal Mishra, proving its resonance with the audience.
A Story of Love and Memory Loss
Saiyaara delves into the poignant love story of Krish Kapur (Ahaan Panday), a short-tempered aspiring musician, and Vaani (Aneet Padda), a shy, aspiring journalist. Their blossoming romance takes a heartbreaking turn when Vaani is diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer`s, forcing them to confront an uncertain future. The film`s sensitive portrayal of love in the face of memory loss has resonated deeply with audiences.This central theme of a couple battling early-onset Alzheimer`s is strikingly similar to the plot of John H. Lee`s acclaimed 2004 Korean romantic drama, "A Moment to Remember." This classic film follows Su-jin (Son Ye-jin) and Chul-soo (Jung Woo-sung) as their relationship is tested by Su-jin`s diagnosis. The film is celebrated for its emotional depth, particularly how Chul-soo supports Su-jin in holding onto their shared memories. A Moment to Remember has inspired several unofficial adaptations globally, leading to the current speculation surrounding Saiyaara.
Also Read: Mohit Suri Reveals Many Filmmakers Dissuaded Him Against Making Saiyaara
Netizens Weigh In: Copy or Coincidence?
The online community has been quick to point out these resemblances. One user on social media wrote, "So #SAIYAARA is a copy of this KOREAN FILM! (Read the synopsis) Mohit Suri has barely made any original film (sic)." Another commented, "Yes totally copy of A Moment to Remember (sic)." Reddit users highlighted specific plot points, stating, "Major plot points are literally the same, like Alzheimer’s, confusion with ex, girl running away. Also, the ending where he recreates the past moment is the same…"However, some have come to Mohit Suri`s defence, arguing that while themes may be similar, the execution and cultural context offer a fresh perspective. One user remarked, “It`s a well-made adaptation even if it is. But I don`t think so, This alzheimers/disease-ridden love story is a common trope among many love stories and it works since it provides a direct emotional connect.”
As of now, the makers of Saiyaara, including director Mohit Suri and producer Akshaye Widhani of Yash Raj Films, have not issued any official statement addressing these comparisons or confirming if the film is an adaptation. Saiyaara is credited to writers Sankalp Sadanah and Rohan Shankar, with previous reports indicating it was envisioned as a "contemporary" Indian love story. Despite the ongoing debate, Saiyaara continues to garner praise for its performances and its chart-topping music, composed by talents like Mithoon and Vishal Mishra, proving its resonance with the audience.
ADVERTISEMENT
Dude, what's your Monday mood?
ADVERTISEMENT
